Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Social Security System (SSS) vs. Aguas

Facts: Pablo Aguas, SSS pensioner, died on December 8, 1996. His surviving spouse Rosanna Aguas filed a claim with the SSS for death benefits. In her claim, Rosanna indicated that Pablo was survived by his minor child Jeylnn. Her claim was approved on February 13, 1997. 

In April 1997, deceased sister, Leticia Aguas-Macapinlac contested Rosanna’s claim, saying that Rosanna abandoned the family abode about 6 years earlier and that she was living with another man. Leticia further alleged that Pablo did not have any children with Rosanna but Rosanna had several children with a certain Romeo dela Pena. SSS suspended the payment of the pension and conducted an investigation. The investigation confirmed that Pablo did not have any children with Rosanna and that Pablo was incapable of having children based on the certification of Dr. Manuel Macapinlac that Pablo was infertile. 

It was on this ground that the SSS denied Rosanna’s request to resume payment and ordered Rosanna to refund to SSS the Php10,350.00 death benefits already released to her and Jeylnn. 

When Rosanna filed a petition with the Social Security Commission, Janet H. Aguas also claiming to be a child of the deceased, joined Rosanna and Jeylnn as claimants. As proof, the petition included a photocopy of Jeylnn and Janet’s certificates of live birth. SSS denied their claims but decided to conduct hearings. During the hearings, the SSC found sufficient proof that Rosanna contracted marriage with Romeo dela Pena while still being married to Pablo; that Rosanna had a child with Romeo dela Pena while still married to Pablo (as evidenced by the baptismal certificate presented to the court for Jenelyn H. dela Pena showing that the showing that she was the child of Rosanna Hernandez and Romeo dela Pena) 

The SSC ruled that because of her adultery, Rosanna was no longer entitled to support from Pablo. As for Jeylnn, the SCC ruled that Jeylnn was not Pablo’s legitimate child, even if her birth certificate was signed by Pablo. The SSC deduced from the records that Jeylnn and Jenelyn was one and the same person. Janet on the other hand was only adopted by Pablo and Rosanna but with no legal papers. 

The Court of Appeals reversed the ruling based on the birth certificates of Janet and Jeylnn showing that they were children of the deceased. 

Issue: Whether or not the petitioners may be considered primary beneficiaries of the deceased for his SSS pension and therefore entitled to the SSS death benefits. 

Held: Only Jeylnn has sufficiently established her right to a monthly pension. 

Jeylnn’s claim is justified by the photocopy of her birth certificate showing the signature of Pablo as her father authenticating that Jeylnn was born on October 29, 1991. Records show that Rosanna and Pablo were married on December 4, 1977 which continued, as far as the records are concerned, until the death of Pablo on December 8, 1996. Based on the records, Jeylnn was born during the marriage of Rosanna and Pablo. Since Jeylnn was conceived or born during the marriage of the parents, she is considered legitimate. 

Petitioner Rosanna married Romeo dela Pena during her marriage to Pablo. A wife who is already separated de facto from her husband cannot be said to be “dependent from support” upon the husband 

Even if the records show that the spouses adopted Janet, there were no legal papers to prove it. She therefore does not qualify as a primary beneficiary

Digg Google Bookmarks reddit Mixx StumbleUpon Technorati Yahoo! Buzz DesignFloat Delicious BlinkList Furl

13 comments: on "Social Security System (SSS) vs. Aguas"

Home Security System said...

blog is nice and informative for all. I have found this blog very interesting because this is really a most informative blog for those who looking for latest technologies for Home Security System in market but afraid of such tactical.

Wireless Security System India said...

Blog is nice and informative, Here you can find All type of information about Wireless security system breaking glass sensors, motion detection alarms, door alarms and window alarms.

Hosneara Begum said...

Interesting post. I have been wondering about this issue,so thanks for posting.

[url=http://www.ea3ltd.com//]Home Security systems[/url]

Radia Chowdhury said...

I think home security system is play the biggest part of our home security. Its nice to have a wireless Security system at home. we can protect our home from any burglar trying to steal anything.
wireless Home Security Systems

Fariha Chowdhury said...

Excellent stuff from you, man I’ve read your things before and you are just too awesome. I adore what you have got right here. You make it entertaining and you still manage to keep it smart. This is truly a great blog thanks for sharing
Wireless Home Security System

Roderick Parker said...

I appreciate the helpful information. Personally, I always leave a useful comment. I get plenty of useless, Pammy comments on my own site that I have to get rid of.
best security systems

vectorobk said...

I found your blog when I was looking for a different sort of information but I was very happy and glad to read through your blog. The information available here is great
Alarm Monitoring

sajib ahmed said...

I am very enjoyed for this blog. I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me
Alarm Monitoring

Farhana awan said...

That was very rational. When deciding to put up security cameras, determine first the areas you’d like monitored. This gadget could be quite expensive if you’d put up one unit in every corner of the house. The key to such problem is proper angling. Home safety is paramount, that’s why it is really good news that home security cams are more affordable now. Having a secure home wouldn’t then be at all impossible for some people.
ea3ltd.com

shakil hossain said...

Therefore glad I found your website searching for shoes.
This is great information at any given time when the internet is full
of falsehoods. Keep up the task in "Link to another good article from Allen Wright" and that i can
come back often.

ea3ltd.com

shakil hossain said...

Therefore glad I found your website searching for shoes.
This is great information at any given time when the internet is full
of falsehoods. Keep up the task in "Link to another good article from Allen Wright" and that i can
come back often.

ea3ltd.com

Anonymous said...

Bear in mind to create the selection of your household and postcode.
IR illuminators can be bought separately to apply
to already installed products. Most of the best modern systems also integrate smart capabilities, which mean that the security
system is part of an overall home automation system.

my web blog home alarm systems dallas tx

Anonymous said...

Users can choose their systems depending upon the size of the property and requirements desired to them.
This can be a fire hazard, especially if you live in an area with high heat.

They could similarly be utilized to stop vehicle drivers from using your gateway
or driveway as a way to turn their autos around.

Also visit my webpage: security systems dallas

Post a Comment